Colts draft RB DJ Giddens - Round 5, Pick 151

[Dam8610]

Originally Posted by IndyNorm

Do you think Edge had fumbling issues since he cost the Colts multiple games and HFA in the playoffs?

Or what about Jerome Bettis? He would have cost the Steelers a SB if Nick Harper's wife wouldn't have stabbed him in the league the night before our playoff game.

Objectively, yes, Edgerrin James fumbled too much. That said, I don't ever remember him fumbling by dropping the ball at the half yard line, and I can’t imagine him doing anything that boneheaded.

Originally Posted by Mr. Session

Bull Shit



Or - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BXsKy1OT0Ho

I loved Addai, I was one of the few people back in 2006 who thought the Colts should draft him over Maroney.

That said, you cherry picked the best juke of his career and a pass play where he wasn't particularly elusive, but just followed his blocks and a bunch of Cheats defenders just fell down. There's no two play selection that will prove or disprove either of our opinions, and if you go look at his whole body of work, you'll see that most of the time, Addai's dancing and juking doesn't create additional yardage.

Here, do this: watch an Addai LSU highlight video, then a Giddens KSU highlight video. If you still can't see what I'm talking about after that, I don't know what to say.

Originally Posted by ChaosTheory

That was a sick cut. But I think I get what Dam is saying. I remember watching Addai all the time, bending like Gumby and half the time he'd lose balance and almost tackle himself. Ha, I'm picturing it now, can't remember the game, but like catching a wide open swing pass and starts juking back and forth with the guy 10 yards away.

Exactly. Addai's juking, shiftiness, change of direction, whatever you want to call it, more often allowed defenders to close on him and reduce his gains than it caused defenders to miss him and increase his gains.

IMO Addai was a really good RB, three down player, had ability as a runner, receiver, and blocker. But elusiveness was not one of the positive traits of his game.