Colts QB in 2022

[IndyNorm]

Originally Posted by ChaosTheory

So apparently they are targeting Carr? I didn't see but I guess McAfee said that on his show yesterday.

I've read some Raiders fans sweating bullets over trading Carr. Bringing up how McDaniels went to Denver and immediately traded Cutler.

From LV's perspective... there's two ways to speculate I suppose... Either they have to have Carr because the division is loaded at QB and no bad teams. Or McDaniels is thinking longer term, takes a haul for Carr, and builds from there.

Wishful thinking on my part, I'm sure.

If McDickface is realistic then he'll probably at least look to move Carr and begin the rebuild, but there are probably 2 things that will hold that up. One is his ego, which I'm sure has him thinking that the Raiders will greatly improve under his coaching. The other is that he's probably not going to get anything near for Carr what he got for Cutler, which was 2 1sts, a 3rd, and the current Bears' starting QB (Orton).

[CletusPyle]

McDirtbag will not do the Colts any favors, if Carr was smart he would demand a trade and not even play for McAsshole, he will screw him over in the end!

[Dam8610]

Originally Posted by apballin

What free agent?

I don’t want any of the listed free agents they’re all just Wentz all over again yes we’d get to keep the picks but that’s not gonna matter unless we figure out the QB

Sign Winston, it's the only play left that isn't basically punting the 2022 season.

[IndyNorm]

Originally Posted by Dam8610

Sign Winston, it's the only play left that isn't basically punting the 2022 season.

If we go FA I wouldn't mind seeing us bring Trubisky in. It could be that his improvement in Buffalo is total BS, but if Daboll is really looking to bring Trubisky with him to NYG then there's probably some truth there.

[apballin]

Originally Posted by Dam8610

Sign Winston, it's the only play left that isn't basically punting the 2022 season.

If we’re going free agents I’d choose Mariota over all of them

Winston has a lot of the same issues Wentz had as far as holding the ball too long and looking for the home run

[Spike]

Originally Posted by apballin

What free agent?

I don’t want any of the listed free agents they’re all just Wentz all over again yes we’d get to keep the picks but that’s not gonna matter unless we figure out the QB

I'm just saying I wouldn't give up the picks for an injury prone average QB. People who haven't watched Jimmy G every week don't know that he is not the answer either. JG has missed 24 games in the past 4 years and is now coming off of shoulder surgery.

Like Dam stated, I would probably go Winston, hell give him a shot. I'm just not convinced about giving up draft picks for any QB that is not that much better than Wentz.

[apballin]

Originally Posted by Spike

I'm just saying I wouldn't give up the picks for an injury prone average QB. People who haven't watched Jimmy G every week don't know that he is not the answer either. JG has missed 24 games in the past 4 years and is now coming off of shoulder surgery.

Like Dam stated, I would probably go Winston, hell give him a shot. I'm just not convinced about giving up draft picks for any QB that is not that much better than Wentz.

Winston is coming off an ACL and is notorious for holding the ball too long he played better for the Saints until he got injured but he was still holding the ball looking for the home run

If keeping picks is the priority then go with Mariota and sign armstead but at this point you just can’t replicate playoff experience…

Jimmy G is 33-14 as a starter 4-2 in the playoffs dude just wins and isn’t afraid of big moments

[albany ed]

Originally Posted by IndyNorm

If we go FA I wouldn't mind seeing us bring Trubisky in. It could be that his improvement in Buffalo is total BS, but if Daboll is really looking to bring Trubisky with him to NYG then there's probably some truth there.

I am inclined to this as well. There are no sure things, but Trubisky intrigues me. He only had 13 starts in college, so if any QB coming into the NFL needed a year to acclimate it was Trubisky. Maybe he can still shine now that he's been in the league for a few years. Also, he's got speed, so he can handle the RPO that Reich is so fond of. Other than Trubisky, I wouldn't be pissed if they chose Mariota, he has even more speed than Trubisky, but I like Trubisky's potential a little bit more.

[Mr. Session]

Am I retarded for thinking Matt Ryan should be in this discussion?

Atlanta needs to get out from his cap hit and I hear Indy has got the money… I think he would be about the best “stop gap” solution Indianapolis could hope for, assuming my ignorance of the salary cap implications related to this don’t make the transaction possible in the first place.

I’ve also lived in Atlanta longer than I lived in Indianapolis at this point, so maybe my perspective isn’t all that objective.

[Racehorse]

Originally Posted by Mr. Session

Am I retarded for thinking Matt Ryan should be in this discussion?

Atlanta needs to get out from his cap hit and I hear Indy has got the money… I think he would be about the best “stop gap” solution Indianapolis could hope for, assuming my ignorance of the salary cap implications related to this don’t make the transaction possible in the first place.

I’ve also lived in Atlanta longer than I lived in Indianapolis at this point, so maybe my perspective isn’t all that objective.

I would take him, but he would cost a lot in draft capital. Carr, Ryan, Winston, or draft someone. In that order.