4th and 8 was my 62-7 moment for the Ballard/Steichen regime.

[albany ed]

Originally Posted by Dam8610

Interesting discussion. I know any GOAT debate is all about opinion, but I feel like how you would answer these two questions should tell you who you think the GOAT is in any sport:

1) You're starting a new franchise and you can pick any player from the history of the sport to start that franchise. Who are you picking?

2) It’s the final drive of the game, your team has the ball but needs a TD to win. Who do you want leading the drive? (This is football specific but can easily be rewritten for any other sport.)

For me, the answer to both of those questions is Peyton Manning.

Alright once more to piss off the peanut gallery.

#1. I choose Peyton Manning

#2
Regular season - Peyton Manning
Playoffs - Tom Brady