Scouting Reports

[Dam8610]

Originally Posted by YDFL Commish

Maybe you're getting better at this Dammy.

Certainly better than when you wanted this guy as our 1st rd draft pick a few years ago:

As I recall Landon Collins was my first choice for that pick, and I'm pretty sure there's a thread on this board that backs me up on that. That said, Kikaha had a pretty good rookie campaign before tearing his ACL, and has been far more productive of a pick than Philip Dorsett.

I also think after that last scouting report is a great time to say again that the player comparisons represent best case scenarios for each player. A more likely high end scenario for Roquan Smith is Deone Buchanon or Donnie Edwards, but if he really buiks up, keeps his speed, and learns how to shed a block the coverage skills and blitzing skills work for it.