Eric, Marshall, Edge, JT

[YDFL Commish]

Rank them. Have at it Freaks!

I gotta give it to Edge, for his longevity as Colt. Marshall may have been the better back over his career and was a slightly better pass catcher, but he's not at the top as a Colts ALL-TIMER.

1. Edge
2. Marshall
3. JT
4. Eric

[Colts And Orioles]

o


I would put Lenny Moore in the neighborhood with all of them, as he was arguably the best dual-threat running back of all-time ...... he is the only player in the history of professional football to have 40-or-more rushing and receiving TD's (63 rushing TD's, and 48 receiving TD's.)

o

[apballin]

If it’s strictly based on their Colts career I gotta go

Edge
JT
Faulk
Dickerson

I’ll say JT is right there and another big season with a postseason run might put him over the top

[Oldcolt]

Edge all day. JT dropped in my opinion last year. He proved in the first half of the year that he can be an incredible pass blocking back when he wants to. He showed he doesn't always want to in the second half of the year. Edge always seemed to be balling out.

[Mr. Session]

Not old enough to have watched Dickerson and I don't feel Faulk was here long enough nor did we really see his prime, although I remember how big of a deal he was when he was here.

I think James is still the clear cut #1 because like Old Colt pointed out, his game was always well rounded.

James made a lot of money in the trenches. He was reliable in there in a way that Taylor simply isn't, which is evidenced by the fact that Taylor's goal line effectiveness is really not as exceptional as his long speed and home run ability.

All that said. Taylor still looks like he has some tread on his tires and if he stays healthy I presume his historical statistical dominance will overtake what James did here, especially when we consider that an entire generation of fans are going to identify with him directly in a way they cannot with James.