The Colts' Placekicking, 2025 Season

[Colts And Orioles]

o


Maybe Michael Badgley can be this season's Matt Stover, and be a solid-but-not-spectacular kicker for the Colts on a trip to a Super Bowl appearance ...... that's what happened in 2009 when Stover had to pinch-hit for the injured Adam Vinatieri.




https://media.gettyimages.com/id/96484718/photo/miami-gardens-fl-matt-stover-of-the-indianapolis-colts-celebrates-after-kicking-a-field-goal-in.jpg?s=612x612&w=gi&k=20&c=0bYBbST2avl3GNz2mxu-nZT7jjJ9CSM0txajduUHqjE=

o

[YDFL Commish]

o


Maybe Michael Badgley can be this season's Matt Stover, and be a solid-but-not-spectacular kicker for the Colts on a trip to a Super Bowl appearance ...... that's what happened in 2009 when Stover had to pinch-hit for the injured Adam Vinatieri.




https://media.gettyimages.com/id/96484718/photo/miami-gardens-fl-matt-stover-of-the-indianapolis-colts-celebrates-after-kicking-a-field-goal-in.jpg?s=612x612&w=gi&k=20&c=0bYBbST2avl3GNz2mxu-nZT7jjJ9CSM0txajduUHqjE=

o

Fuck, I hope he's better than Stover!

[Colts And Orioles]

Fuck, I hope that he's better than Stover !!!





o


Stover was 41 years-old when he kicked for the Colts that season, and he was 9-for-11 on FG attempts and 33-for-33 on Xtra Point attempts.

In the post-season he was 6-for-7, with the only miss coming on a 51-yard attempt in the Super Bowl.

If you were expecting more from him, that would be asking a lot.

o

[YDFL Commish]

o


Stover was 41 years-old when he kicked for the Colts that season, and he was 9-for-11 on FG attempts and 33-for-33 on Xtra Point attempts.

In the post-season he was 6-for-7, with the only miss coming on a 51-yard attempt in the Super Bowl.

If you were expecting more from him, that would be asking a lot.

o

I wasn't expecting more from him. It's the fact that he had no business attempting a 51 yd field goal, and Caldwell should have known that.

[Colts And Orioles]

I wasn't expecting more from him. It's the fact that he had no business attempting a 51-yard field goal, and Caldwell should have known that.





o


Oh, OK. But the way that you worded it implied that Stover didn't carry his weight.

Now that you mention it, a 51-yard FG attempt 16 years ago would be like a 55-yard FG attempt today. 60-yard attempts are not uncommon today, but they were back then. The Colts probably should have gone for it on 4th down with Manning and the offense in that situation.

o

[Colts And Orioles]

o


(vs. STEELERS, 11/02)



Badley kicked a two FG's of more than 50 yard today (52 yards and 53 yards, respectively.)

Badgley is 5-for-5 in FG attempts, and 14-for-15 in X-tra Point attempts so far this season.


Whoever decided to sign this guy appears to have a good eye for kickers.

o

[albany ed]

Cam Little just kicked a 68 yard FG. They have got to narrow the goal posts.

[Colts And Orioles]

o


(vs. FALCONS, 11/09)



Badgley missed 2 kicks today ...... a 32-yard X-Tra Point, and a 53-yard FG attempt.

He did convert on a clutch, 44-yard FG with only seconds remaining in the 4th quarter to send the game into overtime.

o

[Oldcolt]

o


(vs. FALCONS, 11/09)



Badgley missed 2 kicks today ...... a 32-yard X-Tra Point, and a 53-yard FG attempt.

He did convert on a clutch, 44-yard FG with only seconds remaining in the 4th quarter to send the game into overtime.

o



We have to do better than this guy

[AlwaysSunnyinIndy]

Badgley out, Grupe in.


https://x.com/AdamSchefter/status/1995956862181933556

Colts have waived K Michael Badgley.

https://x.com/JoelAErickson/status/1995969751622058439

Colts are signing former Saints K Blake Grupe to the practice squad, per source.

https://x.com/TomPelissero/status/1995973018846392322

In addition to Blake Grupe, the Colts worked out K Maddux Trujillo and K Justin Tucker today.


https://x.com/RomeovilleKid/status/1995970863771124124


Grupe is 75 of 94 on FGs (79.8%) and 86 of 88 on PATs (97.7%) in his career.

However, he’s just 18 of 26 on FGs this year (69.2%).

https://x.com/MikeGarafolo/status/1995969007934210081

Blake Grupe has a history with Colts special teams coordinator Brian Mason, who coached him at Notre Dame in 2022.

Grupe is in line to kick for Indy this week.

[Puck]

Also worked out

Tom Pelissero
@TomPelissero
·
41m
In addition to Blake Grupe, the Colts worked out kickers Maddux Trujillo and Justin Tucker today.


https://x.com/TomPelissero/status/1995973018846392322?s=20

[Colts And Orioles]

o


(vs. STEELERS, 11/02)



Badley kicked a two FG's of more than 50 yard today (52 yards and 53 yards, respectively.)

Badgley is 5-for-5 in FG attempts, and 14-for-15 in X-tra Point attempts so far this season.


Whoever decided to sign this guy appears to have a good eye for kickers.

o

o


And this is why it's a good thing that I am not the Colts' GM ..... it's about the 2,397th time that I have been wrong about something since I started posting here.

o

[Dam8610]

Also worked out

Tom Pelissero
@TomPelissero
·
41m
In addition to Blake Grupe, the Colts worked out kickers Maddux Trujillo and Justin Tucker today.


https://x.com/TomPelissero/status/1995973018846392322?s=20

I hope they don't sign Tucker.

[HoosierinFL]

Grupe’s career numbers look terrible, i cant believe hes an upgrade over Badgley.

Obligatory fuck the raiders.

[Brylok]

Special Teams coordinator Brian Mason came from Notre Dame. Grupe went to Notre Dame. That's why they signed him.

Probably should have just kept Badgely, but we'll see.

[AlwaysSunnyinIndy]

At this point, I would bring back Matt Gay to play the remainder of this season.

I would have been fine signing him to the practice squad after Washington released him and had him ready in case Badgley imploded. But the 49'ers had a need with their kicker Eddy Piñeiro injured and San Fran was able to promise him the job on game days immediately and give him a better opportunity.

The 49'ers have their bye this week and expect Piñeiro back for their next game. So Matt Gay is currently sitting on their practice squad...the Colts could easily poach him right now. But maybe they are allowing San Fran to keep him around in case Piñeiro is not ready.

Matt Gay has been 100% on XP's the last two seasons. His FG completion percentage looked ugly this year because Washington decided to let him attempt a lot of FG over 50 yards - and (as I would expect) that didn't turn out well.

[Colts And Orioles]

o


(vs. SEAHWAKS, 12/14)



Prior to today, l Blake Grupe's l career-long FG was a 57-yarder in 2024 ...... today, he kicked a 60-yarder in the waning seconds of the 4th quarter with the team trailing by 2 points.

o

[Colts And Orioles]

o


(DECEMBER 28th)



Blake Grupe's l is 8-for-8 on FG Attempts, including 3-for-3 from 50 yards-and-beyond.

Blake Grupe's l is 7-for-7 on Extra-Point Attempts.

o

[sherck]

o


(DECEMBER 28th)



Blake Grupe's l is 8-for-8 on FG Attempts, including 3-for-3 from 50 yards-and-beyond.

Blake Grupe's l is 7-for-7 on Extra-Point Attempts.

o
While I liked Shrader, I hope that we plan to retain Grupe for 2026.

[Hoopsdoc]

While I liked Shrader, I hope that we plan to retain Grupe for 2026.

Let them battle it out in training camp.

[Lov2fish]

While I liked Shrader, I hope that we plan to retain Grupe for 2026.

I was eyeball to eyeball with Grupe today. He is a little guy, but I watched him routinely bang em in from long range today in warmups. I don't know, maybe he is Cinderella and it is just a lucky stretch. Why was he available? I like Spencer